Wednesday, March 22, 2006

American Idol

So far this American Idol season: Simon Cowell seems more bored than ever, Paula Abdul seems more incoherent than ever (sometimes to the point of seeming downright inebriated on some shows…I’m not saying that she is but she does seem awfully heavy-lidded and slurry sometimes), Randy Jackson’s hipster routine seems more tired and rote than ever, and Ryan Seacrest’s attempts at wit (especially when trying to slam Cowell) are more lame and annoying than ever.

On the upside, the contestants are as strong a group of singers as American Idol has ever had. As of this writing, Chris Daughtry seems to be the one to beat…he has a great voice, an appealing back story, and a strong sense of who he is and what he does; he’s also not afraid to take chances and, more often than not, he pulls them off. As the judges have said several times I can easily imagine buying CDs by Chris right now.

The rest of the field is filled with some potential stars…Taylor Hicks, Mandisa, Ace Young, and Katherine McPhee among them…and none of the contestants are without some measure of real talent (I could do with less of the “Chicken Little” kid’s smugness but I guess we can attribute that to his youth…and I think that Miss Pickler is overplaying the “ditzy country gal” routine.)

The American Idol juggernaut doesn’t seem to be losing steam yet (as the gold and platinum selling records by Kelly Clarkson, Clay Aiken, Fantasia, Carrie Underwood, Ruben Studdard, and Bo Bice prove so surely) and it will interesting to see who comes out on top during this very competitive season.

* * * * *

3/23 addendum: Kevin "Chicken Little" Covais' fanbase failed him as he got the boot last night. It was a mild surprise since his performance this week was, in my opinion, one of his better ones...but that's the way it goes sometimes on Idol.


Rich said...

Wow, it's nice to see someone who has commentary that is spot on. Thanks for the concise and factual analysis. Great work!

Anonymous said...

I agree shows like "American Idol" looses its steam eventually. Also it's because past winners are not hitting it big as Kelly Clarkston so what's the point right?

The Blog Tribune

Carolyn said...

I was a bit surprised that Chicken Little was sent to the chopping block last night this early in the game. But he wouldn't have won it, they usually keep some like him around to seque between the more mature singers who have a real shot at winning. I suspect Pickler will take his place in that regard now.

Personally, I'm pulling for Chris and/or Mandisa as I believe they have the true star qualities and are the only ones I would buy tickets to see.